home about mark parliament news from mark community news contact me
A crisis that demands the recall of Parliament

Calls to recall Parliament are a regular feature of the long summer recessevery year, and the current clamour for a recall of Parliament to discussthe current crisis in the Middle East has been dismissed by some as a knee-jerk reaction, particularly as the House of Commons had a debate onthe issue just before it rose for the summer.

But the current crisis is one that fully justifies a recall, for a number of reasons. Firstly, it is clear that grass-roots opinion in this country is horrified at the daily scenes of slaughter caused by attacks on innocent civilians. Like other MPs, I have been inundated with calls from constituents who want me, as their representative, to ensure that their concerns are voiced, and are bewildered and angry that MPs have no way of voicing those concerns in a collective fashion. Secondly, and more significantly, there is little doubt that public opinion is at odds with the policy of the British government on the current crisis. The perceived alignment of the British government with the Bush administration and the tacit backing for Israel’s actions in Lebanon is one which does not have the backing of the public, and it certainly does not have the backing of a large number of MPs, including the majority of Labour MPs (as well as Labour Party members and trade unions). This lack of support for the policy was apparent in the House of Commons debate three weeks ago. Given that the views expressed in that debate do not appear to have had much effect so far in changing the government’s policy, then it is even more appropriate that there should be an opportunity for MPs to make clear in
no uncertain terms that there is a need for a change of government policy on Lebanon and the current crisis. A recall of Parliament, therefore, would be an opportunity not just to wring hands in despair, but a positive opportunity to influence the approach which should be taken by this government at international level on the issue.

Last, but certainly not least, a recall of Parliament would allow Parliament to give voice to the widespread concern that the current crisis could spiral out of control into a wider conflict which could engulf the entire Middle East with consequences for the entire world (and this week’s security alert at Britain’s airports is a timely reminder of how our daily lives in the UK are intimately linked with what happens in the wider world).

It certainly seems clear that there are some in Israel and the USA who would like to see the current crisis escalate into an all-out military conflict aimed at bringing down the current regimes in Iran and Syria. Even if that is not the intention of the US administration (and I’m sure it is not the intention of the British government), the risk of that escalation occurring as a result of a wider and wider extension of the current war is only too clear. The consequences just for Britain and British interests surely justify giving MPs a chance to send a clear message to government that people in this country do not want to see that escalation, and instead of a ratcheting up of the conflict, they want to see a de-escalation of the crisis, and a renewed focus on efforts to settle the underlying causes of the current conflict – not least a just and equitable settlement in Palestine. It is surely right for MPs to be able to express those views before there is any further escalation of the conflict.

This article originally appeared in the August 11th 2006 edition of The Scotsman
Click here to see the article in The Scotsman archive
Back to Articles >>>
Israel Lebanon and Gaza: Question to the Prime Minister
Mark Lazarowicz (Edinburgh, North and Leith) (Lab/Co-op):
Of course Israel has the right to self-defence against terrorism, but surely what is going on now in Lebanon and Gaza goes far beyond any legitimate self-defence. Must not the world community make it clear that if it is unacceptable, as it obviously is, for Hezbollah and Hamas to fire rockets at civilian targets in Israel, it is also unacceptable for Israel to target civilians and civilian infrastructure in Lebanon? The world must say that clearly, or it will encourage those in Israel and those on the other side of the conflict who want to provoke further action leading to further military conflict on a wider scale throughout the region.
18th July 2006, Col 160
Call for immediate cease fire: Question to the Foreign Secretary
Mark Lazarowicz (Edinburgh, North and Leith) (Lab/Co-op):
When the UN Secretary-General’s special envoy reports to the UN later today, will the British Government support a call for an immediate ceasefire? People in this country see what is happening on their television screens and they want to see our Government taking a lead in the international community and doing everything that they can to stop the violence on all sides now, immediately and with no qualifications.
Back to Speeches
20th July 2006, Col 513
Early Day Motion 2568 LEBANON: supported by Mark Lzarowicz
Link to EDM on Pariament web site
Mr Andrew Love
John Austin
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr Crispin Blunt
Lorely Burt
Frank Cook

Glenda Jackson • Mrs Betty Williams • Richard Younger-Ross • Frank Cook

That this House expresses grave concern about the escalating crisis in the Middle East that has now spread to Lebanon; notes that Israel's disproportionate military actions in Gaza and Lebanon, including an air and sea blockade of Lebanon, attacks on the airport in Beirut on 13th July and the killing of at least 35 Lebanese civilians within the first 24 hours, risk provoking further regional conflict by seriously jeopardising the fragile political landscape in Lebanon; condemns Hizballah's rocket attacks on Israel and the abduction of Israeli soldiers; urges the British Government to call for an immediate cessation of violence from all parties and to condemn the killing of all civilians on all sides; and calls on all sides to respect the other's sovereignty and international law and to release all prisoners held illegally without trial as a means to end the current crisis.

Love, Andrew
Austin, John
Corbyn, Jeremy
Blunt, Crispin
Burt, Lorely
Cook, Frank
Jackson, Glenda
Williams, Betty
Younger-Ross, Richard
Pound, Stephen
Prentice, Gordon
Russell, Bob
Starkey, Phyllis
Hopkins, Kelvin
Jones, Lynne
Lazarowicz, Mark
Lepper, David
Burden, Richard
Cohen, Harry
Cryer, Ann
Cummings, John
Gibson, Ian
Hancock, Mike
Berry, Roger
Bottomley, Peter
Salter, Martin
Keetch, Paul
Luff, Peter
Marsden, Gordon
Caton, Martin
Conway, Derek
Dean, Janet
Durkan, Mark
George, Andrew
Gerrard, Neil
Turner, Desmond
Vaz, Keith
Soulsby, Peter
Singh, Marsha
McCafferty, Chris
McDonnell, Alasdair
Meale, Alan
Osborne, Sandra
Breed, Colin
Campbell, Ronnie
Dobbin, Jim
Drew, David
Godsiff, Roger
Betts, Clive
Wareing, Robert N
Goodman, Helen
Khan, Sadiq
Pope, Greg
Ruddock, Joan
Harvey, Nick
Marris, Rob
Francis, Hywel
Hamilton, David
Bayley, Hugh
Weir, Mike
Hemming, John

13th July 2006